McCarthy recorded a one-over-par 73 to win the 18-hole event by one stroke over two golfers from Pitt-Bradford and one from PSU-Behrend.
The Shenandoah men played the par-72, 6997-yard Sinking Valley Country Club and finished tied for third overall with a 311. PSU-Altoona won it on a tiebreaker over PSU-Behrend; both sets of Lions shot 308.
SU tied with Pitt-Bradford for third in the 11-team event.
The Shenandoah 'B' team shot 329 to finish eighth.
- Connor McCarthy 73 1st
- Josh Bianco 77 T-10th
- Joe Gesell 79 T-15th
- Robert Fox 82 T-32nd
- Erich Gall 85 T-40th